Consider the Alternative: Why Alternative Investments Have a Place in Your Portfolio
By Aaron Hodari, CFP®, CIMA®
Think about the characteristics that make a strong portfolio: diverse, cost-efficient, tax-efficient, risk-managed.
These qualities should be true of every portfolio, no matter the size or an individual’s risk profile. The clients we meet with all want a portfolio that checks these boxes, but doing so is easier said than done.
This is why we often look to alternative investments. The world of alternatives provides access to unique opportunities that, when used correctly for the right investor, can help achieve the portfolio traits mentioned above.
Why Alternatives?
The catch-all phrase of “alternative investments” is a bit of a misnomer, since it can mean different things to different people. Hedge funds are alternative investments, as are structured settlements and cryptocurrency assets (but that’s a discussion for another day).
The reason we preach the value of alternatives to certain clients is because they can have a low correlation to the U.S. stock market, which comprises many investors’ main risk exposure.
Achieving an asset mix with low correlations helps protect against downside and bouts of volatility, especially as traditional assets are becoming more correlated than ever. As BlackRock noted, alternatives took less heat during the dot-com crash and financial crisis compared to their mainstream peers.
On top of this, alternatives can generate higher rates of returns due to the wide scope of their investment universe. But of course, not all alternatives are created equal. With this in mind, there are two types of alternatives we feel make a strong case for portfolio inclusion: real estate and private debt.
Real Estate
Perhaps the most well-known type of alternative investment, real estate investing has become increasingly popular in recent years. We find real estate attractive in part for its returns. The average 20-year return of REITs (11.8 percent) residential real estate (10.6 percent), and commercial real estate (9.5 percent) all outperform the S&P 500 (8.6 percent).
The total equity market cap of the FTSE Nareit All REITs Index is over $1.1 trillion according to the National Association of Real Estate Investment Trusts, more than double the market’s $438 Billion value in 2007. This growth is due in part to the increasing variety of REIT specializations and countless fintech platforms that have democratized access to the market, increasing investor exposure to the market.
However, the rising popularity of real estate investing has had an unintended consequence: it has increased the correlation of the asset to equities and the overall market. This can be problematic for us, as we are generally trying to diversify away from equities when including a real estate allocation in a client portfolio.
This is why we prefer to allocate to non-publicly traded real estate funds over publicly traded REITs. Private placement real estate gives us access to institutionally managed real estate assets directly valued by leading firms without having to worry about external market forces having an impact on price and volatility. It’s a best-of-both-worlds solution for our investing needs.
Private Debt
In the wake of the financial crisis, many traditional lenders scaled back their business lending activity, paving the way for institutional funds and investors hungry for entry into the private lending markets to get a bigger piece of the pie.
And the market is expected to continue to grow, both in the U.S. and abroad. A 2017 report from the Alternative Investment Management Association said the global private credit market will break the $1 trillion threshold by 2020. AIMA CEO Jack Inglis called the private credit market “a permanent feature of the lending landscape.” Inglis noted that performance across the industry continues to be strong relative to other asset classes, which in turn has attracted more fundraising from investors.
Why would investors flock to such an obscure, illiquid type of investment? It comes down to returns. In a survey from BNY Mellon, 96 percent of respondents said private debt had performed at or better than their expectations—higher than for any other type of alternative investment.
According to Preqin, between June 2013-June 2017 private debt funds recorded double-digit annualized returns. Direct lending strategies led the charge, returning 13.8 percent. Between the rising rate environment and equity’s volatile 2018 finale, the returns for an uncorrelated asset class like private debt are hard to argue with. Diversification, manager selection, and an understanding of the illiquidity are critical – but for the right investor, it can be a valuable part of the portfolio.
The Right Alternative For The Right Investor
These investments are not for everyone. As Legg Mason points out, alternative investments come with quite diverse returns. Their liquidity can vary greatly as well.
But for the right investors who have the desire, capital, and risk profile to look elsewhere, alternatives can provide a great cushion to protect your portfolio and potentially increase your returns.
There’s a place for traditional investments with every investor, but don’t forget to consider the alternatives when building your portfolio.
Investment Risk: Alternative investment products, including real estate investments, private equity, hedge funds, and other notes & debentures, are considered highly speculative, involve a high degree of risk, and therefore may not be suitable for all investors.
Alternative investment managers often engage in speculative investment practices, such as the use of leverage, that may increase the risk of investment loss, can be highly illiquid, are not required to provide periodic pricing or valuation information to investors, may involve complex tax structures and delays in distributing important tax information, are not subject to the same regulatory requirements as mutual funds, often charge high fees which may offset any trading profits, and in many cases the underlying investments are not transparent and are known only to the investment manager.
Aaron Hodari is a managing director at Schechter, a boutique, third-generation wealth advisory and financial services firm located in Birmingham, MI. For 80 years, Schechter has quietly advised wealthy families on financial matters including: Institutional quality investment advisory services, private capital and alternative investments, advanced life insurance planning, income and estate taxes, business succession and charitable planning. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and many not reflect those of Schechter or their affiliates.
